• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Robert Feest Insurance Agency

All of your Insurance Under One Roof

  • About Us
  • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Auto Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Business Insurance
    • Health Insurance
    • Specialty Insurance
  • Blog
  • Request A Quote
  • Contact Us
  • 262-641-0644

Determining the Guaranteed Replacement Value of your Home

June 28, 2017

“If I could SELL my house for that amount, I’d do it TOMORROW!”

– An insured client that shall remain anonymous

Many Homeowners confuse Market Value, which is what a home is worth based on comparable homes, school district and location, or Assessed Value which is what your local government bases your property taxes on. There is also Actual Cash Value, which is mainly used for very old homes or rental properties, in which you would simply take the payout and not rebuild. Co-insurance penalties may apply.

So…how can homeowners be comfortable that their home has an appropriate replacement cost, and make sure they are not over- or under- insured?

Open your Homeowners Insurance Policy to the Declarations Page and look for the section titled “Dwelling” or “Coverage A”, which  applies to the structure of your home including walls, ceilings, floors, doors, windows, cabinets, fixtures, and roof. The best way to explain this is to imagine turning your house upside down, opening the roof and giving it a good shake. Whatever does not fall out, is Coverage A. That listed amount is the most the company will pay to repair or rebuild your home today at the current cost of material and labor in the event that it is damaged or totally destroyed by one of the poicy’s named perils such as fire, wind and hail. (Earthquakes and Floods are NOT covered, but can be purchased separately if needed or desired).

Most Insurance companies have their own Replacement Cost Estimator that we use to determine an accurate value of your home. It factors in the year your home was built, type of construction, room count, number of bathrooms, square footage, quality of building materials, attached decks, and type of roofing and siding. There are many additional costs factored in, such as Fire Department service charges, board up services, water or smoke damage clean up, tearing down of existing structure and debris removal, as well as architectural fees, landscaping and any of your municipal building code required updates.

Most companies offer guaranteed, or extended replacement cost coverage, which will pay 25% above the coverage a dwelling limit to cover cost overruns or price surges that follow natural disasters. Being an Independent Agent, I carry several companies that offer Guaranteed Replacement cost coverage with NO CAP, which will pay whatever it costs to rebuild your home, or Blanket limits, which offer some extra flexibility, as long as you are properly insured to value.

A Marshall & Swift research study updated in 2014 found that 64% of U.S. homes are undervalued by an average of 19%, which could result in the homeowner paying out of pocket costs, or cutting corners on size and quality of the rebuilding process.

You will also notice you have additional coverage, with separate limits for Coverage B: Other Structures, such as a garage or outbuilding, Coverage C: Personal Property,  and Coverage D: Loss Of Use if your home becomes uninhabitable. The limit for these three categories of coverage is usually a percentage of your dwelling limit, and I will get into those coverage and details in a later post.

If you are interested in checking into the replacement value of your home, you can check out www.e2value.com, for a replacement cost appraisal on most homes for $25 each.

You can also call me for free advice on all things insurance. We’ve been located in Elm Grove since 1995, and we shop the companies so YOU don’t HAVE to!

Filed Under: Coverages Tagged With: homeowners insurance, Market Value, Replacement Cost

Primary Sidebar

Get in touch

850 Elm Grove Rd
Suite 18
Elm Grove, WI 53122
Get Directions
(262) 641-0644
Contact
Mo,Tu,We,Th,Fr 9:00 am – 5:00 pm

The form below is for new customers that want to obtain a new quote. If you are an existing customer and have other policy issues, changes, or questions, please call our office at 262-641-0644 or send an email to gary@rfeest.com

Request a call

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
How did you hear about us?*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Footer

Elm Grove Office

850 Elm Grove Rd
Suite 18
Elm Grove, WI 53122
Phone: 262-641-0644
Fax: 262-784-6433
Contact us

We Shop the Companies


So YOU Don’t Have To!

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Licensed in Wisconsin, Arizona, Florida, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, North Carolina, Tennessee & Texas

© 2025 Robert J. Feest & Associates. All rights reserved.